Ina Garten Yogurt Mint Sauce Recipe

Jump to Recipe

Ina Garten’s yogurt mint sauce is a cold, creamy condiment made with Greek yogurt, fresh mint, fresh dill, scallions, lemon juice, olive oil, and a pinch of crushed red pepper flakes, all pureed in a food processor. It makes 1 cup, takes 5 minutes of active time, and needs at least 2 hours in the fridge for the flavors to develop.

This recipe comes from How Easy Is That?, where Ina serves it cold alongside hot grilled lamb chops as her Greek Lamb with Yogurt Mint Sauce. The whole dinner is designed around make-ahead: “you marinate the lamb and make the sauce a day in advance. All you need to do before dinner is grill the lamb and serve it hot with the cold yogurt sauce.” The contrast of the cold, herby sauce hitting the hot, charred lamb is what makes the pairing work.

The food processor puree is what separates this from a stirred yogurt sauce. Processing the scallions, mint, dill, red pepper flakes, olive oil, and lemon juice into a coarse paste first breaks down the herbs and releases their oils. When the yogurt goes in, those flavors distribute evenly through the whole cup instead of sitting in chunks. Stir it by hand and you get bites of raw scallion next to bites of plain yogurt, which tastes uneven and sharp.

FAQs

Why does Ina use both mint and dill in the sauce?

Mint on its own can taste one-dimensional in a yogurt sauce, almost medicinal if you use too much. Adding two tablespoons of fresh dill rounds it out with a grassy, slightly anise-like note that makes the sauce taste more complex.

The combination is common in Greek and Middle Eastern cooking, where herbs are rarely used alone. Ina’s version also gets depth from six scallions and a pinch of red pepper flakes, so the finished sauce has warmth, freshness, and a little bite all at once instead of just tasting like minty yogurt.

What should you serve yogurt mint sauce with?

Ina designed it specifically for grilled lamb chops, and the cold sauce against hot charred meat is the classic pairing. But the sauce works with almost any grilled or roasted protein because the yogurt cools the palate while the herbs add brightness.

Try it alongside grilled chicken thighs, roasted leg of lamb, seared salmon, or spooned into a pita with falafel. It also works as a dip for warm flatbread, a topping for grain bowls, or a dollop on roasted vegetables like eggplant or zucchini. The lemon and scallions make it versatile enough to go with almost anything savory.

How is this different from Ina’s Radish Tzatziki?

Ina’s Radish Tzatziki from Cook Like a Pro is a different approach. That version uses grated radishes squeezed dry, garlic, yogurt, olive oil, lemon juice, scallions, and mint. The radishes add a sharp, peppery crunch that the yogurt mint sauce doesn’t have.

This yogurt mint sauce is smoother and more herb-focused. No radish, no garlic, and the dill takes the place of the raw bite that garlic or radish would add. The mint sauce is elegant and mild. The radish tzatziki is spicier and more rustic. Both use the same food-processor-then-chill method.

Can you make yogurt mint sauce ahead of time?

This is one of Ina’s designed-for-ahead recipes. She says to make both the sauce and the lamb marinade “a day in advance” so all you have to do before dinner is grill the meat. The sauce actually improves overnight because the mint and dill oils seep deeper into the yogurt as it sits.

It keeps in the fridge for up to 3 days in a sealed container. After that the mint starts to darken and the flavor turns grassy instead of fresh. Don’t freeze it because the yogurt separates and turns watery when thawed. A fresh squeeze of lemon juice right before serving can brighten a sauce that’s been sitting for a day or two.

Can you substitute dried herbs for fresh?

No. The entire flavor of this sauce depends on fresh mint and fresh dill. Dried mint tastes dusty and medicinal in a cold yogurt sauce because there’s no heat to wake up the oils the way there would be in a cooked dish. Dried dill tastes like hay.

This is a 5-minute recipe with only nine ingredients, and the fresh herbs are doing all the heavy lifting. If you can’t find fresh dill, use an extra quarter cup of fresh mint and a tablespoon of fresh flat-leaf parsley instead. But skipping the fresh mint entirely means you should make a different sauce altogether.