Ina Garten Cucumber Tomato Salad Recipe

Jump to Recipe

na Garten’s cucumber tomato salad is hothouse cucumber, cherry tomatoes, red and yellow bell peppers, and sliced red onion tossed in an oregano-garlic vinaigrette with Dijon mustard, then finished with chunks of feta cheese and kalamata olives. It serves 6, takes about 15 minutes to assemble, and needs 30 minutes of resting time before it hits the table.

This recipe appears in Ina’s Barefoot Contessa How Easy Is That? cookbook (2010) as “Greek Panzanella,” which includes pan-fried bread cubes, and on Food Network as “Greek Salad” without the bread. In the cookbook headnote, she writes “what’s not to love about toasted bread soaked with vinaigrette and tossed with tomatoes and cucumbers?” and calls the Greek version “with feta and olives even better.” The breadless version on Food Network is the one that maps to what most people picture when they search for a cucumber tomato salad: just vegetables, dressing, and cheese.

The technique that makes this salad taste different from the one you throw together at home is the 30-minute rest before serving. Ina says to “set aside for 30 minutes to allow the flavors to blend,” and that wait is not optional. The salt in the vinaigrette draws juice out of the tomatoes and cucumbers, which mixes with the olive oil and vinegar into a pool of seasoned liquid at the bottom of the bowl. That liquid dresses the feta and olives from underneath, so every bite tastes cohesive instead of like separate ingredients that happen to be in the same bowl.

FAQs

Why does Ina let the salad rest for 30 minutes?

The rest is when the salad actually comes together. Salt in the vinaigrette draws moisture out of the tomatoes and cucumbers over those 30 minutes, creating a pool of seasoned vegetable juice at the bottom of the bowl. That liquid mixes with the olive oil and vinegar and dresses the feta and olives from underneath.

Serve the salad immediately after tossing and you taste each ingredient separately: plain cucumber, plain tomato, a hit of dressing here, a bite of feta there. After 30 minutes, every component tastes like it belongs together. Ina specifies “at room temperature” for the rest, not in the fridge, because cold slows down the juice release.

Can you add bread to make this a panzanella?

This is exactly what Ina does in the cookbook version. She pan-fries 6 cups of 1-inch bread cubes in olive oil with salt and pepper for 5 to 10 minutes until browned, then tosses them into the salad alongside the feta and olives. The bread soaks up the vinaigrette and tomato juices and becomes chewy and flavorful.

Use a rustic, crusty bread with an open crumb. Soft sandwich bread disintegrates. The key is adding the bread right before serving so it absorbs liquid but still has some crunch. If the bread sits too long, it turns to mush. That is why the Food Network version drops the bread entirely: without it, the salad holds for hours.

Can you make cucumber tomato salad ahead of time?

Without the bread, this salad holds well for several hours at room temperature or overnight in the fridge. The vegetables soften slightly but the flavor improves as the vinaigrette soaks in. Pull it from the fridge 20 minutes before serving and taste for salt, since cold food always needs more.

The cucumbers eventually release enough water to dilute the dressing, so beyond one day the salad starts to get watery. If you are making it a day ahead, drain off any accumulated liquid at the bottom before re-dressing with a splash of vinegar and a drizzle of olive oil.

What other cucumber salads does Ina make?

Ina’s Creamy Cucumber Salad from Back to Basics (2008) takes cucumber in a completely different direction. She drains sliced cucumbers overnight, then dresses them with strained yogurt, sour cream, champagne vinegar, and dill. It is cold, creamy, and rich where this Greek version is bright, tangy, and olive oil-based.

She also makes a Middle Eastern Vegetable Salad from the same How Easy Is That? cookbook, which adds chickpeas, scallions, mint, parsley, and basil to the cucumber-tomato base with a lemon-garlic vinaigrette and feta. That version is heartier and works as a standalone lunch.

What should you serve cucumber tomato salad with?

This is a side dish that pairs with anything off the grill. Lamb chops, chicken souvlaki, grilled shrimp, or a simple steak all work because the bright vinaigrette and salty feta cut through the richness of grilled meat.

For a two-salad lunch, pair this cool, Mediterranean plate with Ina’s Kale Salad Recipe for a contrast of cold and warm. The crispy pancetta and Pecorino in the kale salad play against the feta and olives in this one, and together they cover enough textures and flavors to make a full meal without any cooking beyond toasting the croutons.